Sahih Muslim Hadith 77

English

[77] Hasan Al-HulwânI narrated to me, he said: "I heard habâbah say: "Abdul-Quddüs 3S :Ji – JL used to narrate to us and say: – :J "Suwaid bin 'Aqalah."t11 Shabâbah said: 'And I heard 'Abdul-Quddüs say: "The Messenger of Allah forbade 4 J ) using Ar-Rawzu 'arian." It was JL – said to him: "What does that mean?" He said: "It means making a small window in a wall to let the breeze pass through. ,[21 Muslim said: I heard L *.a…. j [L Jul 'Ubaidullãh bin 'Umar Al- QawârIrI say: "I heard Hammâd : JA 4,jly21 bin Zaid say to a man – a few days after MahdI bin Hilâl arrived: 'What is this tainted :— Ja spring coming from your direction ?'t3' He said: 'Yes indeed, 0 Abü Ismâ'Il." 1'] While the name is Suwaid bin Ghafalah. The issue here has to do with the phrase Yuttaicjjadfi ar-n2h ghardan (taking a living creature as a target), which is the correct wording of the narration. However, it was misread and recited by 'Abdul-QudCis as Yuttaiçjyzdj ar-raw/i 'aradan (making a space to let the air in). Both of these examples were mentioned to demonstrate his lack of abilities as a narrator. (31 Meaning that he felt he was weak and not fit to narrate Hadith.