Sahih Muslim Hadith 74

English

[74] Abü Dâwüd said: "Shu'bah said to me: 'Go to Jarir bin Hâzim and tell him: "It is not permissible for you to narrate from Al-Hasan bin 'Umârah, because he tells lies." Abü Dâwüd said: "I said to Shu'bah: 'How is that?' He said: 'He narrated to us from Al-Hakam things for which I find no basis." He said: "I said to him: 'What things?' He said: 'I asked Al- Hakam: "Did the Prophet offer the funeral prayer for those who were slain at Uhud?" He said: "He did not offer the prayer for them." But Al-Hasan bin 'Umârah said, narrating from Al- Hakam, from Miqsam, from Ibn 'Abbâs, that the Prophet offered the prayer for them and buried them. I said to Al-Hakam: "What do you say about the children of Zina (children born out of wedlock)?" He said: "The funeral prayer should be offered for them." I said: "From the HadIth of whom is that narrated?" He said: "It is narrated from Al-Hasan Al- BasrI." But Al-Hasan bin 'Umârah said: "Al-Flakam narrated to us from Yaiyâ bin A]-Jazzâr, from 'Ali, may Allah be pleased with him."